Why Strength Training is Better than Cardio

You’ve heard it time and time again: “Exercise is good for you!” “You have to exercise to stay healthy.” And although any exercise is better than no exercise, it is becoming more and more clear every day that strength training is more beneficial with a greater range of benefits than cardio.

What is strength training?

Strength training, also known as resistance training is using some kind of weight to lift to get a workout. When we think about strength training, many of us think about buff, leering, self-involved dudes at a Gold’s Gym. But it’s so much more than that. You can strength train by lifting weights or using exercise machines, but you can also strength train by practicing certain kinds of yoga, playing parkour, or even by lifting your children into the air. The weight used can be an external weight or the weight of your own body.

What is “cardio”?

This term is short form for ‘cardiovascular exercise’ and usually refers to increasing your heart rate a certain amount for a protracted period of time. This typically involves running for long periods of time, brisk walking, swimming, or biking. Cardio is not considered a strength training exercise; you are not lifting anything when performing a typical cardio workout. (And please, I beg you, for the love of your healthy joints, don’t lift weights while you’re in motion!) 

What kind of exercise is most effective?

It is important to recognize that any form of exercise, so long as it is not causing injury or illness, is better than not exercising at all. In general, exercise allows for the development of coordination and motor skills, increases endorphin production and therefore feelings of happiness. It promotes stress reduction, pain reduction, lowers blood pressure (long-term), enhances the immune system, and decreases the risk of developing chronic diseases. (Uh, hell yes, sign me up, please.) You should be able to run away from an angry pig. You should be able to use your body to pull yourself up a rock to safety.

But, if you are looking to get the greatest benefit out of exercise while reducing the risk of harm, strength training is what I recommend. When exercising, it is ideal to put your body under the least amount of stress possible while receiving maximum benefit. When you go for a long run or bike ride you are actually doing the opposite. Exercising at low intensity for long periods of time taxes your joints and organs tremendously. When you exercise you produce reactive oxygen species, also known as free radicals. The longer you exercise, in general, the more you are producing. These free radicals are the things that cause damage at the cellular level and increase the risk of developing disease. Several studies have shown that long cardio sessions increase the release of cortisol (a stress hormone), raise the risk of cardiac disease, can cause scarring on the heart, and lead to insulin resistance, which increases the risk of developing type-2 diabetes.

What we understand now is that although cardio exercises can help you get in shape to some degree, a far more effective approach to exercise is strength training.

When you lift moderate to heavy weights three times a week with proper form you have the ability to control the stimulus you are inflicting on your muscles much better. You reduce the risk of injury tremendously because of this. There is much less of a chance for you to lose proper alignment or misstep which is often a cause of injury. High intensity strength training has been shown to be the most effective way to enhance fat loss and increase muscle mass. Strength training also improves insulin sensitivity which lowers the risk of most chronic diseases.

Additionally, strength training improves mobility and balance, posture, increases bone density, and reduces the risk of osteoporosis. What is even more awesome about strength training is that you get all the benefits of cardio without all of the risks! If you perform a set of an exercise and only wait 30 seconds before jumping in to the next set, you will get your heart rate up and improve your conditioning. I will often drop to do a set of pushups to get my heart rate up, or pick up a kettlebell and do some swings. (Please be sure that you have someone show you how to lift properly and give you feedback on your form. You may need to hire someone for this, but it’s well worth mitigating the risk of injury, which will cost you much more in the end.

More reps lower weight or fewer reps higher weight?

Lifting moderate to heavy weights with good form should provide tremendous, noticeable benefits in a relatively short period of time. You will probably start noticing benefits within a month and marked differences in your body shape and tone by the third month. To be honest, it can suck at first as your body gets used to this type of exercise, but it is worth it!

Again, if you’ve never lifted weights before, get the help of a qualified personal trainer. They will put you on the right track so you get the best use of your gym membership. And, remember, hours and hours of cardio is probably doing you more harm than good, and it is definitely not necessary for your health and fitness goals. You’ll reach your goals much quicker by incorporating a strength training routine into your week. Doing some cardio, if you enjoy it, is perfectly fine, but it is important to recognize that strength training is essential.

Yours in Health,

Please use the icons below to save or share this article.
Tag me, I’m @DrSamanthaND.



Cook This: Lemon-Walnut Green Bean Salad.

This recipe (and photo too ) is pulled directly from a lovely blog called “The Whole Life Nutrition Kitchen.” Some of the recipes are a bit bland for me but others have become staples in our kitchen. This lemon-walnut green bean salad is fabulous. I’ll just post the link as it’s great as-is. The one thing she recommends is adding the walnuts at the end...

Read More

Getting Started with a Gluten-free Lifestyle. Part I- Resources.

gluten-free flour package by Bob's Red Mill

So, your physician has recommended a gluten-free diet. Or, you’ve seen how much better your best friend feels after following a gluten-free diet for just a few months- she’s lost weight, has more energy and seems more like herself. You want to give it a try. But where to start? The first thing, before diving in, is to understand the difference between celiac disease, gluten...

Read More

Cook This: Easy Dairy-free Pumpkin Pie

My girlfriend Laura made this pie a while back and posted a link to the recipe on her FB page. She raved about it so I decided to give it a shot. I was surprised to see that not only is it dairy-free but also very simple to make; just my gig as I don’t particularly like to bake. Not to mention that my four-year-old...

Read More

Product review: Chebe

This gluten free bread mix was recommended to me a few years ago. It turns out that this mix is based on a traditional Brazilian cheese bread called Pão de queijo. Similar breads are also found in Bolivia, Paragua, Argentina and Colombia. They can be made from scratch or more commonly from a mix. The main ingredient is usually Cassava or Tapioca flour, and in...

Read More

Cook This: Thai Chicken with Shallots and Basil

I’ve been buying Cook’s Illustrated at our local health food store for years. Not until about a year ago did I realize that it is the magazine version of a PBS series called America’s Test Kitchen. We don’t get cable (gasp!) so to find a good cooking show on network TV is a crazy jackpot for me. The fabulous thing about this magazine (and show)...

Read More